Re-Reading Game Of Thrones: Catelyn I

What does this have to do with the Israeli/Palestinian conflict?

12:56 Sophie looks so precious

Q&A: Maybe I skipped this on twoiaf, but where did the first men come from? It has to be Essos, right? Where did they come from in Essos? We have a fully detailed tale of the andals and their coming, and even some of they background, is there any such info for the first men?

Very interesting. Great video 👌

She thinks the Westwood was was listeningthinking it's slow deep thoughts…

This chapter starts to hint that just like this world, all religions are in the eye of the beholder and have strong cultural aspects.

Unlike this world, there is actual evidence that there is something tangible behind religion on Planetos.

For best game of thrones , movie and tv show reviews go to nerdsoup channel , leave this shit its boring now its not funny .i just unsubscribed

Love the concept of this series, but i can't help but feel like the speed at which the chapters are reviewed needs to be ramped up a bit. Perhaps slightly longer videos covering two chapters at a time to help get through the book quicker? Keep it up though love it!

loving this series, thanks dudes! keep up the awesomeness!

What made Itamar decide to move to Florida, of all places? If it's about the weather, why not California? I really wanna know

The Tel Aviv-Fla eoaphical divide really wasn’t bad, guys. Good video. Plus it gives you the opportunity to fill the screen with the ridiculous random video footage. I️ burst out laughing when the deep sea fish slowly opened its mouth…

A lot of noise coming from Gil's mic. Also would be nice to make the faces bigger. Other than that good execution. Hi Itamar.

it's funny that catelyn was written to depict the north as this inhospitable place but even in her chapter, the north still comes off as this beautiful inert winterland. it's as if grrm made the north look like this under-appreciated ancient wonder with the weirwood trees and the cotf, contrasted by catelyn's extroverted sensibilities. it's like she's this foreigner who never really acclimated to this unyielding environment.

YES.

Ned's religion like Druids. Caitlyn more like Egyptian religions. ❤️

I was sold two minutes when the dolls drifted on screen. This is SO GOOD.

Been reading along with this series 🙂 Thank you for doing this even though youre nowhere near eachother, appreciate your work

What do you think about the idea that "winter is coming" is a threat in the vein of "our blades are sharp"? Could it tie in with the Kings of Winter, or the possibility that the night king is a Stark?

Random Stargate is random

I’m reading along! Thanks guys!

When it comes to Ned telling Catelyn he should never argue with a Tully I thought the impression we were supposed to get was that he was playfully teasing her not like demeaning her or being passive aggressive.

What you really sense in this chapter is that you're in for more than your average fantasy novel. There are many very complex fictional worlds but this one is pretty unique in the sense that is so well thought through, things are not only features that are either different or similar to ours but with GRRM they are for a reason.
I loved Gil's observation about the weirwood trees – I completely overlooked it but I think it is important: We all associate trees with the good and throughout the books and more so in the TVseries we are lured into sympathy with the North and its values. This very early little line gives us a hint towards th fact that things will be not as easy a they seem and that the lines between good and evil might be very blurred.

ned, my nanny naddi, my schmutzi? best part of this episode:)

I love that you are using fan art that doesn't look like the show actors. It helps me de-show-ify my mental images.

Hype!

OOO de guys! i have a question, i am a patreon so you has to answer, who is de INFJ? is it itamar, and what is gil? de infp? is intj or de istp?

Fabulous job editing this video! Must have taken a long time but it was worth it.

I would have done this Nerd Soup style, with cartoons. Think about it.

Hey guys, you should look into giving these videos an overall number within the book.

It's great watching this as released, but when people go back to watch this series, they could lose track of their order.

What is sleepy kitty’s name?

This might seem counter-intuitive, but I wonder how these would be received as just audio. It would be easier to mask the distance between you.

I love this! Thank you for all you do!

I've been waiting for a channel to do a re read of GOT. Thanks guys

FLOATING HEADS