Hogwarts reacts to GoTS05E02 “The House of Black and White” (part two)
.
.
.

New to the channel? Check out our Intro and Q&A’s to see what we are all about!

Follow us around everywhere else!
Twitter: @hogwarts_reacts
Instagram: @hogwartsreacts

Questions, Comments, or Promotional Requests?
Email us at ravens@hogwartsreacts.com

Send us love letters here:
Hogwarts Reacts
PO Box 60726
CHICAGO, IL 60660

source

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

50 COMMENTS

  1. If I had been Dany, I wouldn't have sentenced the former slave to die, just throw him in jail for a year or so or maybe even pardon him. I mean The Sons of the Harpy are essentially an insurgent/terrorist group, not exactly an innocent "murder" victim there. However I would make it clear that anyone else goes around my orders again, THEN the punishment would be death. But it was a bit harsh to execute him for disobeying her only once, particularly due to the context. I would have given him another chance.

  7. season 4 was great tyrions speech the mountain and the viper, incest baby dead…i like season 6 because they brought back my 2nd fav character but i hate it coz they killed my fav character….. Long Live Lord Bolton…

  9. hi … it was one of dany,s mistakes she regrets doing as you seen . but its a hard thing to do being queen , like she said the law is the law . but yeah . season 6 is amazing . cant wait to see your reactions to each episode of that season . and season 7 was good as well .

  10. Was that execution stupid? I think not. Probably one of the wisest things Dany had done in Mereen. If she hadn't slaves would think they could do anything they like, since she is their Mysa.

  15. Love that Stannis and his wife are on the hate list but what after 5×09? Is there something worse than the hate list for them? Btw did you understand that last scene of Dany with Drogon? I really hope you did and get the whole point after watching 5×09 😉

  21. Love how in part 1 San brings up a Stark was elected Lord Commander at 10. Since it’s voted on he must have been a badass, then in this episode you first hear about Lyanna Mormont who is also 10.

  28. NO ONE ACCUSED ROB STARK OF DOING WRONG when he executed that one guy who killed Lannister kid because HE HAD TO , also NO ONE ACCUSED JON SNOW OF WRONG when he executed that lord commander who hid with gilly during battle just for disobeying his order because HE HAD TO , SO WHY THE HELL PEOPLE HAVE DOUBLE STANDARDS WHEN IT COMES TO DANNY , Danny did the RIGHT THING cause she also HAD TO , all the choices she made here and after were right and somewhat tough/harsh and complicated but never Really Wrong , and eventually by end of season 7 everyone did realize that and mostly acted positive towards danny so it’s all good ,,, only snowflake social justice warriors kind people started speaking against her decisions by start of season 7 but they soon silenced when sensible people understood and supported Danny so I just hope u don’t get carried away by EMOTIONS and only think rationally when it comes to Danny 🤞🤞✌️🙂

  30. People complaining about the seasons after season 4 are so ridiculous lmao. Especially the argument about it being too predictable and not doing what Game of Thrones usually does. Well shit clearly you guys want the show to become predictable by killing people you like off, just like how you want and expect to happen. The story is coming to its climax, arcs are coming to and end, and plotlines are colliding. Sure, the writing isn't as strong, but is in no way the illogical trash you guys speak of. Smh you people just can't enjoy things. ANYWAY with that being said, loved the reaction as always :)))

  31. The law is the law. It seems unfair, but honestly just calling her "stupid" is making light of some incredibly complicated politics. If she let him go or made his punishment lenient, it would send a message to the rich masters that she was unjust. They'd hate her and feel oppressed and probably rebel against her. If she punished him exactly as the law dictated, it would make the poor people hate her because they saw her as the "mother" of the poor to defend them from the masters.

    What she did wasn't stupid. It was Lawful Good instead of Chaotic Good. If she spared him, she still would have had hatred and rebellion, except from the Masters instead of the slaves, and it would be deserved hatred because she went against her own laws out of empathy. Kindness doesn't play a part in justice.

  32. That guy murdered a prisoner awaiting a fair trial. It's like if a cop at the county jail murders a prisoner awaiting trial because he doesn't want the possibility of a fair trial. But justice demands that the people of Merene understand that when a crime is committed there is a fair proceeding and justice will be done. Not vigilante mob justice. The job of the jail house guard is not to do what was done which is be judge, jury, and literally executioner. The people of Merene wanted mob rule and vengence. But that's to be expected of slaves. Dany is trying to teach a different way. A way of law and order. A fair trial and punishment. That's what she did with the murderer of the prisoner, the punishment was death and the sentence was carried out. The problem is now she 's trying to reason with a mob with no understanding of how to create an ordered society of shared law. All they know is the slave master and the most powerful rule with violent oppression. But logically, Dany did did makes sense big picture. What, was done was a jailhouse guard killed a prisoner. Most people in a society with a western legal system would say that has to be punished, it's murder, and mob executions fundamentally damage believe in your societies legal system. It just means now you have a mob that only wants mob justice.

  33. I dont get why people complain about have to wait for the episodes weekly. Waiting is part of the fun. Watching all in a row sucks because then its over so quickly. Ive watched every season from tge start every week and didnt complain at all.

  35. I honestly cannot wait to see the reactions to the seasons 6 and 7. Despite some moments where I could be caught swearing at the writing and decisions the showrunners made, it still has so many awesome moments that completely tilt the balance for me and still makes them my top favourites next to seasons 4 and 1 (because the first one just IS that special to me i guess). Really cannot wait to see Hannah react to those, honestly cannot XD

  38. Anybody who says season 6 is their favorite is just blinded by 3 great episodes that really uplifted the relatively mediocre other 7. Episode to episode season 4 just can't be matched.

  43. The difference between Jon and Dany: Dany had to have Tyrion explain to her why killing someone who is loyal to you even when they were in the wrong is a bad move. But Jon knew by instinct not to do that.

  46. "why did she do that?" oh Hogwarts you sweet summer child. You are adorably innocent xD

    She did that because if the rules apply to the masters they also apply to the former slaves… She's trying to impose a rule of law that applies to all 🙂

    You adorable you xD

    Ps: your predictions are out of this world xD

  47. I am loving these react videos, but I'm getting very impatient waiting for new vids. I'm just so excited to see your reactions and it's difficult being patient knowing you already have all the footage up till current GOT. Can we possible get two in one day every once in a while? That is,two episodes of Got with parts one and two. What a wonderful surprise it would be to get a double Hogwarts dose in one day. Thanks and keep up the great work!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here