Robert’s Rebellion Game of Thrones Prequel Movie!

Love the idea of all this cast except macavoy just because he's a little to old for me I'd I think Jamie bell would make a good ned

Tom Hardy as Robert is perfect!

We need something that's more and it seems like that your more into it because Aegon conquest or dance with dragons would be more epic because we're getting Roberts Rebellion so why we need it as a motherfuckin movie I mean come on and plus are you motherfuckin kidding me I would love to see Aegon conquest or dance with dragons that's more badass plus I think the only reason you definitely feeding into them saying this because you want it to happen

' If GRRM isn't involved, I don't want to see it"
Bullshit! You'll watch it. If for no other reason than to pick out every fault with it.

the dance of dragons civil war or targerion's civil war whatever you would call it, would be my number 1 movieor prequel series, then robert's rebellion

Second time I watched this. If only…

This seems like an unlikely cast. Too many names that won't do it. Also James macavoy is too short and hobbit like to be ned.

Brandon Stark, Lyanna Stark, and Ashara Dayne. Don't like the Rhaegar casting. Love Ned Stark's

bad Jaime cast.Shouldnt he have long hair?

If they are being true to the story, they need much younger actors for just about everyone.

Aerys was only 39 when he died.

Definitely some talented actors lined up if the rumors are true. But I couldn't agree more with you–if GRRM isn't in it, good acting would be wasted. The Dunk and Egg stories might be a better choice.

I really enjoy your commentary. Wonderfully done.

So have you switched from longer videos to shorter ones? Still enjoyable, I was just curious

I made a Vid calling for this about 1 year ago

The movie will make money so a Robert's Rebellion storyline could happen. I'm with you on having GRRM involved to do it right tho. It's refreshing seeing a fellow NYC hiphop head getting hooked on ASOIAF series. I don't have many friends left these days let alone ones that will geek out on books with me. Cheers Tony.

I agree w/you Tony, and I don't think GRRM would let someone make the movies w/o his involvement, right? I hope not.

I think rollo from vikings would make a great robert baratheon

Tony , I'm back , been overseas , gotta catch up on the videos I missed
But I was thinking, they should do a book, or cartoon or something, on the war of the nine penny kings, dunk and egg, etc

Oh wow, I would love a movie about Roberts Rebellion. There are so many juicy mysteries that need to be uncovered from that time period. I personally am very suspicious of all the hiding and swapping around of babies. I wonder if Elia's children were actually killed by The Mountain. I suspect that Sir Ilyn Paine had his tongue cut out not because he offended Aries, but because he knows something about or helped with the baby swapping. Then his house was given Poderick Paine as a ward. Now Poderick is seemingly repeating history, (Dunk and Egg Tales) with Brienne. Then there are Ashara Dane, Rhaella Targaryen, and of course Lyanna Stark who all had babies. I really need to know about all these babies!
I have really been enjoying your theories and collaborations with James of Thrones! You all are so much fun.

i would love to see a prequel on the dance of dragons. though im sure the cost of recrewating the dragons will keep it from ever being done. after that id love to see something on Aegon the Unworthy….that would be a drama filled show.

sad thing is we will prolly see this movie before we see winds of winter

george specifically said he didnt want this to happen… no respect…

I think Robert's Rebellion would be a good setting for a show but after having read A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms I am leaning towards Dunk and Egg.

A lot of the major characters in Robert's Rebellion are in their late teens or about 20. To me, the actors proposed above are too old, regardless of their acting ability.

They should call it "Usurper!"

Somewhere George said that we would know everything about Robert's Rebellion by the end of the story. I agree that it should be have George involved. The only way anything else should be made from his world is if the story is complete.

Howland Reed is missing. Why am I not surprised.

James is too little to play ned.

I've heard rumors about a Dunk and Egg series to follow the Game of Thrones series and its also supposed to be on HBO, I'm not sure if they plan on using the same creators but I assume they will if it actually transpires. I like that concept but a Robert Rebellion movie could be Awesome if it was long enough or made into 2 parts, and like Tony said if George RR Martin was involved extensively with its creation. #WePullTheStrings

would love to see a dunkin egg show or even the andal invasion would be great. I watch as much GOT's videos as possible and yours are the best. I can't believe you don't have over a million subs. thanks for all you do to keep me entertained.

Seriously doubt we'll get a Robert's Rebellion "Movie". That would actually be the perfect scenario to set another series in. There's no Dragon's at that time period, magic is not as prevalent as it in during the current series, or in the earlier years. Those reasons alone make it more attractive to a show producer, because CGI won't be as heavily relied upon. If they were to do a movie, it would have to be a multi picture deal, most likely 3. Anything less than that wouldn't be able to do it justice. As far as GRRM being involved in writing it? He needs to finish ASOIAF, first. Either a new series, or Movie venture would consume too much of his time, and he's said he won't allow that to happen again.

+TeflonTv I would love this, it is what I want! I want something similar with the Marauder Era for HP Series. Arron Taylor is perfect for both Benjen Stark and James Potter, you might not be a fan; of HP but I love both Series equally!

I would love to see a Duck and Egg series.

It was looking pretty feasible until I saw Naomi watts and tom hardy. I love Both those actors… Even James McCvoy was too big of a name. I'd rather see a series covering the dunk and egg stories.

Roberts rebellion in 2 1/2 hrs? GRRM's characters can't be captured in that time IMO. That's one great thing about ASOIAF, the characters and their personal journeys & growth / downfalls

both would like a movie about the dragons coming to the land

Well damn pretty good casting. Tom Hardy as King Robert #fire

The hype hit me when I saw Tom Hardy as Robert. This needs to happen!

What the hell? Tom Hardy is wayyy too small to be Robert Baratheon.

If GRRM writes it, I'll watch it.

THIS NEEDS TO HAPPEN!!!!

If it was just a 2 hour movie they could probably do a pretty good job with minimal input form George. However, a long running series could get to far out there without George

damn this cast is perfect. they need to make this happen.

lol I'd love to see Tom Hardy in a Game of Thrones movie!

I would rather have Robert's Rebellion as show then as a movie and your Tony if George R.R Martins is not involved then the movie is not even worth watching

You are right, Don Teflon, that unless George RR himself is involved in this movie's creation, it is doomed to mediocrity at best!

One casting "decision" which surprises me for this movie, is Benjen Stark. You would think that Robert's Rebellion would demand characters like Stannis Baratheon, Brandon Stark, Rhaegar Targaryen, Mace Tyrell and even Jon Connington… not Lord Stark's last kid and third son!