First 150 viewers will get three meals off their first Blue Apron order free!
CLICK HERE ►►
This video is sponsored by Blue Apron.
Join Wisecrack! Subscribe! ►►
Support Wisecrack on Patreon! ►►

Death Note is all about justice, but what exactly is it trying to say? In this Wisecrack Edition, we’ll dive into Death Note’s unique exploration of justice, injustice, and potato chips. Join us as we explore the philosophies of Light, L and more.

=== Get the Show! ===
DVD/Blu-ray ►

=== More Anime Philosophy! ===
ONE PUNCH MAN ►
FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST BROTHERHOOD ►
ATTACK ON TITAN ►
GHOST IN THE SHELL ►

Check out the Wisecrack Podcast!
iTunes ►►
Google Play ►►
Or wherever you get your Podcasts!

=== Join us on Social Media! ===
FACEBOOK ►►
TWITTER ►► @Wisecrack

Get Email Alerts ►►
Get Wisecrack Gear! ►►

Written by: Claire Pickard
Directed by: Michael Luxemburg
Narrated by: Jared Bauer
Edited by: Mark Potts
Assistant Editor: Andrew Nishimura
Motion Graphics by: Drew Levin
Produced by: Jacob Salamon & Emily Dunbar

© 2017 Wisecrack, Inc.

source

31 COMMENTS

  1. I can't comprehend how someone could ever think Light is anything more than a mass murderer. That he has good intentions doesn't take away from the fact that a significant number of people he killed were innocent. He has the morality of a Fascist or Communist or- more on the nose- a religious fanatic.

    Sure, not all the Jews are greedy bankers subverting our society, but you can't make an omelet without breaking a few eggs. We have to kill them all just to be sure we get the bad ones.

    Any dissent must be crushed. Right from the moment where he kills L's stand in for having the audacity to criticize him he has all the morality of a commissar beating someone to death in a gulag. For the greater good, comrade.

    He even does it with reckless glee instead of treating it like a somber duty. His hubris adds an extra layer of disgust for me. A religious fanatic, where he is his own god. No humility, which again reminds me more of dictators with cults of personality like Hitler or Stalin or Mao than it does say inquisitors or witch burners.

    The cherry on top is that most societies like this don't actually create a utopia. The moment where people threaten each other by suggesting they will post their name and photo to Kira forums online showcases this is a society, a world, where people are living in fear. Fear that they might do something that could displease Kira, fear that they don't always know what he will consider fair and what he will want to punish. They are all at his whim and mercy.

    If Light had stopped at killing people with hostages or dangerous criminals at large his morality MIGHT be ambiguous. But he didn't.

    As to what I think justice is? I think its obvious. I'd rather let a hundred guilty men walk free than punish one innocent mistakenly. Light would rather punish a hundred innocent men than let one guilty one walk free.

    I also believe in exponential increases. That people should be judged with the same harshness they judged others with while performing injustices.

    Someone flips you off in traffic? Don't be a pansy. It happens. Let it go.
    Someone steals something minor from you? Hey, return it and no harm no foul.
    Someone drives recklessly? Fines are fine.
    Someone punches you? Punch them back.
    Someone steals something major? Jail time.
    Someone murders in the passion of the moment? Major jail time.
    Someone murders for frivolous reasons? Execution.

    Someone like Light though? Notice I didn't mention torture as a punishment at any point. You save it for people like that. It really isn't enough for people like him- people that sit in their ivory towers while murdering scores of their fellow man and patting themselves on the back congratulating themselves on what a great job they've done- to simply die.

    Everything they've ever loved should be turned into ashes in their mouth first. Their retribution should be thousand fold. They should be made an example of, as an individual.

    Maybe some of you think what Light did was okay because you have the mentality of a Bolshevik or a Nazi. Maybe some of you should be impaled and lit on fire.

    Why not? He emotionally manipulated a woman completely devoted to him then had her light herself on fire when she ceased being useful to him. Even fucking Walter White loved those closest to him enough that his son berating him destroyed him as a man. If Light can't be hurt that way he should be flayed alive instead.

  2. L is a detective character, though he is a refreshing character from the usual ones we see. He does however have the motive of capturing the culprit, and bringing the world back to its ordinary state. (Returning things to how they were prior to the crimes)
    The author wanted to right a suspense story, since there weren't many in the audience range they wanted to write for. It is a really neat spin on the old cat and mouse detective story.

  3. one theme you didn't address here and that seems important too is the theme of good and evil: does a crime condemn you for your whole life and means you have to die or can it be redeemed, cured? Light thinks he can bring peace by killing the "bad guys" and not by chasing the very societal reasons those persons became criminals in the firts place, which is very moralizing and totally wrong IMO. On the other hand, you have L who fights the biggest criminal of all times with sometimes very crude/borderline cruel method. The protagonist of the show is a killer! Morals and the (blurred) concepts of good and evil seem paramount!

  4. I'm quite certain that Amartya Sen articulated the same idea – that we should work to correct easily noticeable injustices, rather than think about ideal justice conditions – before Zack did in his "The Idea of Justice".

  5. In this anime I didn't get what kira's perception of justice is…!! Bcz he said bad ppl Must b killed Thn Y did he kill innocent ppl who came as obstruction in his way of being god of new world.. I think he want to become dictator ..His ego increases n yeah at last all v can expect is light would get bore when there is no culprit left Thn start killing innocent ppl too…here the answer to what is true justice is not stated….!!
    Actions of light n L is acceptable if v were in those place……
    Lastly world become same as how it was before kira..!!
    Finally kira is nothing more than less than a common man a serious serial killer……The classy attitude of L is just Osum…overall luv this anime.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here