Why Andrea Should Have Lived! The Walking Dead’s WORST Decision Ever Made?

Now carl dying is the worst mistake

Nobody knows shit here. Andrea would have been an awesome character if she was written right from the start and I know this by being a fan. Nobody has read the comics, or has listened to what MOVIEidol has said. Fuuuu-kin' helllllllLLLLLLlllllll. The retardation meter is so high it broke a thousand times over and IS STILL goin'. People want to hear what they want to hear and that's it. You can't fix stupidity.

Rick & Andrea> Richonne

If she was still alive.. she’d be one of Negans Wives for sure 😂👍🏻

Jokes aside I think they really messed up killing Andrea it sucked.
Rick & Michone as a couple are cringe😂

hated her

I think Rosita is sort of replacing Andrea

Wow I didn't know that I really wish they kept her for that but as far as the show she really did have a shitty story so I was kinda glad she died but as I was reading the comic I'm like wow she is good a character don't get me wrong I love Rick and Michonne but as I'm reading and seeing this I would of loved to see where she would of went

But Andrea was a TERRIBLE character on the television series. She was nothing like her comic book counterpart. She was totally annoying, naive, and actually pretty stupid. I'm glad she died. Not a mistake at all.

Andrea was my favorite character in the tv.. They didn't gave her a chance like merle..

They still could have brought her back right? Like we never saw her actually die. We heard the gunshot but still , and we never saw her get bit , she could have pretended to die for some reason just to maybe get the governor her self?

Does anyone remember her perfectly pedicured toes when she was trying to pick up those pliers? Who’s doing nails in the ZA?

Plz give me that bundle thingy

:-/ Ya man, I don't think you can even compare Andrea in the show to Andrea in the Comic's. I was also pretty upset/frustrated about how they handled (or rather MIShandled) Andrea's character in the show but they had already murdered her character loooong before they actually killed her off. Just absolutely terrible casting/acting, and equally terrible (if not worse) writing for one of the better characters in the comics…It sucks to say but I think dead/no Andrea is better than the Andrea they gave us in the show… Same goes for Carl but even worse… I know I probably sound like I'm being a bit harsh but in my opinion Andrea and Carl are 2 of the best, most dynamic/interesting, and likeable/rootable characters in the Graphic Novels and I guess I just find it kind of inexcusable to fail that hard when the source material is that good. They need to get some consultants from Game of Thrones! Lol

I do agree that this was a bad decision. I have no problem with inter-racial relationships but I simply don't feel Richonne… The kissing scenes look like they're holding back… I think Rick and Andrea would have a more interesting relationship and that as a duo interrogating hostiles and so forth I think they would be a lot more fun… There's a lot of characters on this show and fans can keep up… I think that Carol would still work but that is probably the best argument for why Andrea not being there is justified. Andrea also was portrayed as being very self centered and basically not very sympathetic. Like her dying like that was punishment or Satisfaction for her sins. But they made a hero out of Father Gabe or Gabie as Negan calls him. Carol had probably the biggest transformation which sometimes does happen with battered women when they are liberated from their tormentor. Certain characters have remained somewhat static like Tara. Yes, she was with "Brian Heriot's" group but she was completely innocent in my opinion and if she had any blame that was just part of her character anyway.

They really need to just give Robert Kirkman full creative control of the show.

Well i think, AMC is promoting racial mixing, that is why they paired that niggress to rick, srsly man, i would bang andrea both in the comic and the show, AMC is obviously pushing it down our throats, that rick and the niggress fit together, succs man.

Andrea was crap. Horrible stupid person.

She died because the actress that played her ruined the character beyond repair. She sucked so bad and I’m so so so so so glad she died. Best death ever.

How can one guy run over the writers and everyone?

To all the morons saying that they are glad Andrea died and think Michonne is a better leading lady for Rick… I've never seen so many ass-backwards dumb-fucks in my life, so typical of a generation that has forgotten what good storytelling is.

Well yeah she shouldn't go so early… That was a very poor decision, not all surprises are good I guess… But if they keep on changing the story in the comics for TV, they could at least have saved Glenn… Way too many "big" losses for the group.

Andrea was smokin' hot…that's really all she added to the show.

To this day it's the one death I'm still pissed about.

I️ don’t understand why his decision wasn’t overruled. It would seem to me that the creator of the show would have the final say over the showrunner.

People hating Andrea became she made stupid decisions, like, don't we all? Some more than others we all mess things up now and then.